What NFL Experts Said About the Seahawks’ 2012 Draft

December 29, 2012

seahawks-logo-helmetThe Seahawks have clinched a playoff spot and have a slim chance of winning the NFC West.

They have a fantastic rookie QB in Russell Wilson, who was drafted in the third round and very well might win Offensive Rookie of the Year ahead of the No. 1 and and No. 2 picks in the whole draft.

They have a budding pass rushing star in Bruce Irvin, who was drafted in the first round and currently leads all rookies in sacks with eight.

They have an excellent rookie MLB in Bobby Wagner, who was drafted in the second round and leads the team in tackles and might get consideration for Defensive Rookie of the Year.

Overall, seven of the Seahawks 2012 draft picks have seen considerable playing time this year. By any measure, it was a GREAT draft for the Seahawks. And that’s what makes some of these “expert” draft grades so funny. (Note: Thanks to Geordie Romer for a tweet that inspired this post.)

Donald Wood, Bleacher Report

Gave Seattle an “F” grade. Drafting Wilson was “by far the worst move of the draft.” Drafting Wilson and Irvin were “the two worst moves of the draft.”


Jason Cole, Yahoo Sports

Gave an “D-” grade overall. Says Russell Wilson will “be lucky to be Seneca Wallace” and the Seahawks “are no closer to solving the QB situation now than they were before 2011.”


Pete Prisco, CBS Sports (Round 1 grades and Round 3 grades)

Overall, he gives Seattle a “C+” grade. He calls Wilson a “strange pick.” Says Melvin Ingram, who was picked by San Diego at No. 18 and has one sack in 15 games so far this season, would’ve been a better pick.


Matt Miller, Bleacher Report

Gave Seahawks a “D” grade overall. Called Irvin a “grab.” Says Seahawks “messed up” by drafting Wilson. Says those two picks were “just bad.”


SI.com (author not listed)

Seahawks get a “C” grade overall for their “blah” draft. Seahawks were “bonkers” for picking Irvin. Says that Wilson “has a bright future, even if Seattle didn’t really need him.”


Vinny Iyer, Sporting News

Overall grade is a “D.” He says the Seahawks drafted “defensive head-scratchers.”


Dalton Johnson, Bleacher Report

Gave the Seahawks a “C-” grade. Says the Seahawks draft was “full of reaches,” including all three top picks — Irvin, Wagner (or “Wager”) and Wilson.


You might be wondering what Mel Kiper — ESPN draft guru — had to say. His full grades are “insider” content on ESPN.com, but this Mike Sando recap says that the ESPN crew gave Seattle a “C-” grade — tied for the lowest of all 32 teams — and that Kiper said he had “huge questions” about the Hawks draft.

To be fair, some of the writers above admit that it’s best to wait a couple years before really grading a draft, but that sure didn’t stop them from making some ridiculously wrong immediate reactions to what the Seahawks did.

Who Got It Right (or Close to Right)?

John Czarnecki did a pretty good job on Fox Sports. He called the picks “one shocker after another” but gave the Seahawks a “B” grade. He had good things to say about both the Wilson and Irvin picks.


On NFL.com, Chad Reuter only gave the Seahawks a “C+” grade, but didn’t completely dismiss the Wilson pick (he’s a “reliable reserve.” Heh.) and praised the Bobby Wagner pick.

Moral of the Story

NFL “experts” sometimes don’t have a clue what they’re talking about. And sometimes, the guys in an NFL team’s front office have a better idea about which college players are good draft picks and which one’s aren’t.



  • Reply Sheila December 29, 2012 at 3:53 pm

    I love this post!

    I was fortunate enough to get to watch Russell Wilson play for the NC State Wolfpack for 3 years. I recall the recruiting analysis when he was in high school. Many questioned whether he’d make it as a college quarterback because of his height. I love that he’s proven the naysayers to be wrong.

    In addition to his ability to make/extend plays, his leadership is outstanding.

    Another quality of Wilson that I admire is that he’s vocal about his Christian faith.

    I’m thrilled for Wilson that he’s thrived in the NFL. There’s a lot of Wolfpack fans that continue to cheer him on.

  • Reply Matt McGee December 29, 2012 at 11:18 pm

    Thx Sheila — we’ve become big fans, too. I was skeptical for a while, but he’s been amazing this year. It’s been a while since I’ve heard anyone suggesting he shouldn’t have been our starter. And yep, the fact that he’s a Good Person on top of it makes it even more enjoyable.

  • Reply scott bronkema April 15, 2013 at 10:52 pm

    Thats why you don’t read bleacher report. Its all crap!

  • Leave a Reply